Start Seeing Diversity
It is natural
for children to notice the differences around them. It is their way of figuring
out the world around them and where they fit in. It is often our reactions to
their questions that send them the wrong messages about what they see.
I witnessed a
child asking her mother why another child was in a wheelchair. The mother did
not answer her, Instead of answering her, she told her child not to stare at
the child in the wheelchair. I had my youngest daughter with me and she
immediately asked me why that mother did that. I told that my daughter that
some people are not sure how to handle those types of situations. My daughter
looked at the child in the wheelchair and the mother, smiled, then said and
waved hello to them.
What I know
from this experience is that children learn about our differences through what
they learn from the adults around them. The child who asked why the other child
was in a wheelchair was just noticing these differences and trying to make
sense between what she knows and what she sees. The child had not yet formed
any judgments/biases about these
differences until the mother confirmed that noticing differences is shameful or
wrong. It also marginalizes the group of people who are differently-abled by
making them seem not “normal” and dehumanizes them.
If this child
were one of my students and told me about this situation, I would have used
what I have learned through my experiences and through what I have learned
about anti-bias education to guide the child to better understand the
differences around us and that it is okay to explore these differences. I would
let this child know that he was not wrong in noticing that the child in the
wheelchair was different from him (Laureate Education, n.d.). Instead of
noticing differences as something shameful, we could begin to explore people
with varying abilities through books, picture cards (Laureate Education, n.d.),
and through answering children’s questions (Hall, 2008). Through my experiences
with working with people with varying disabilities, I would be able to explain
to my students how much they have in common with them. All children want to
learn, play, and to be loved and appreciated. They have family, friends, and
classmates. I feel by making these connections would help children see them as
people rather than something taboo that they should not notice or talk about. We
want children to feel that they are free to ask questions in order to create a
world with less bias and prejudice. Until we show children we need to change
how we value others, we will not be able to move towards creating change (Harro,
2010).
References
Hall, K. W.
(2008). Reflecting on our read-aloud practices: The importance of including
culturally authentic
literature. Young Children, 63(1), 80–86.
Harro, B. (2010). The cycle of
liberation. In M. Adams, W. Blumenfeld, C. Castaneda, H.
W.
Hackman, M. L. Peters, & X. Zuniga (Eds.), Readings for diversity and
social
justice
(Figure 7.1 on p. 53, 2nd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge.
Laureate
Education (Producer). (n.d.). Start seeing diversity: Physical ability and
characteristics [Video
file]. Retrieved from:
Laureate
Education (Producer). (n.d.). Start seeing diversity: Race/ethnicity [Video
file]. Retrieved from:
Trish, thank you for sharing your experiences. I think in today's society, we are so quick to judge and believe that different comments made are rude. If we can start to form these differences into learning experiences and teachable moments for young children perhaps we can eventually change how these differences are viewed in society. I think you made a great point when explaining this to your daughter that a lot of adults are unsure how to explain differences to children. I think using books, videos, and pictures is a great way to expose children to differences.
ReplyDeleteBrianna
Hi Patricia,
ReplyDeleteYour daughter’s comfort with others who are different from her was displayed by a wave and a smile. I am sure this is by way of your teaching her to accept all for who they are. It appears that the mother of the other child took on the colorblind position which results in denial of young children’s awareness of differences and to nonconfrontation of children’s misconception, stereotypes, and discriminatory behavior, whether it be their race, culture, gender or different physical abilities.
Pelo, A. (Ed.) (2008). Rethinking early childhood education. Milwaukee, WI: Rethinking Schools.